This week, writer Hanna Rosin has the Internet alive with buzz about her article in the April issue of Atlantic Monthly, entitled,
"The Case Against Breastfeeding." In it, she addresses one of the key issues in The Mommy Wars and wonders if breastfeeding is the 2009 equivalent of the vacuum cleaner, tying women to the house, keeping them from their careers, goals and equality with men. She also delves into some of the research concerning the benefits of breastfeeding and whether or not breast milk is a magical elixir that produces smarter and healthier babies.
I was dismayed by Rosin's piece, because I felt like she managed to portray all breastfeeding mothers as nasty, cliquey, judgemental bitches who only nurse because it's the cool thing to do, and because I felt like she chose the medical studies that proved her point and skimmed over those that disproved it.
However, I was also dismayed to read a number of blog entries and dozens of comments from women who were exactly what Rosin talked about--nasty, cliquey, judgemental bitches who use breastfeeding as the ultimate good mother litmus test, and who neglected to realize the importance of treating others as decent, loving people worthy of respect.
Being respectful of others doesn't mean you have to change your ideals or completely rearrange your life or inconvenience yourself for someone else. Being respectful of others doesn't mean you loudly and vehemently defend your actions when you haven't been challenged. Being respectful of other moms means understanding that not everyone agrees with you and being okay with that.
I respect a person's right to be uncomfortable with breastfeeding. I respect a person's right to wish that all breastfeeding mother's would use a blanket. I even respect a person's right to prefer naked boobies in a magazine over nursing boobies. I may not agree with you, but I respect your right to have those opinions. And I will be discreet. This does not mean that you can change my mind or that I will go feed my baby in a filthy bathroom. It means that you go your way, I'll go mine, and we'll be fine. It means that you bite your tongue and I'll bite my tongue and we'll agree to disagree.
Purposely doing something to ignite someone else's ire? It's just bad manners. The breastfeeding mother who sits down next to a bottle feeding mother, spoiling for a fight? Bad manners. The old woman who gives the stink eye to a breastfeeding mother who is completely covered? Bad manners. The woman who stands in a crowded room and makes eye contact with as many people as possible before whipping out her breast and making a big production of nursing without a cover? Bad manners. Celebrities who compare public breastfeeding to masturbating and radio DJ's who call lactating women "sows?" Bad manners.
My mother-in-law is uncomfortable with breastfeeding. Her first child, my husband, was born in the early 70's, when practically no one was breastfeeding. She's a private, reserved, prim and proper woman, no more likely to wear a plunging neckline than to flop out a boob in public. She never said a word to be me about being uncomfortable, but I could tell. I could tell by the way she skittered out of the room when I needed to nurse. I could tell by the way she averted her eyes. And because I respect her, I was discreet.
I never used a blanket, but I also never exposed my breast. Not only did I not want to make any around me uncomfortable, there were people I just didn't want to see my boob. Like my dad. Or my boss. Or the creepy guy who lives down the street and leers at me when he says hi. So I was discreet. My baby got fed in the manner I wanted, and no one was offended.
Please do not misunderstand. I'm an advocate for breastfeeding and I think it's important. But, in this case I also think a little sensitivity and tact can go a long way. If a woman is breastfeeding and is completely 100% covered up and someone has a problem with the mere notion that she is breastfeeding, that's too bad. Not my hang up to worry about. But even if the law says you can parade down the street topless with a baby attached to each nipple doesn't mean it's advisable to do so.
I believe in breastfeeding and I believe that all women should be educated and empowered to make the best decisions for their families. But does that mean stepping on a woman's feelings and alienating our fellow mothers all for The Cause? Of course not. Because the only person a woman needs to justify her choices to is herself.
If you want to do something, push for better maternity leave, increase public acceptance of breastfeeding in public and make it easier for all women to express milk at work, regardless of where she works and how much money she makes. But, in my opinion, being In Your Face just isn't going to cut it when it comes to doing those things. Instead, quiet perseverance, constant education and a sense of pride--instead of combativeness--would be more effective.
I've done both. I nursed both kids as long as I could, and when my milk dried up, I switched to formula and fed them that way. I was lucky enough to never encounter someone who judged me for bottle feeding and received nothing but positive feedback when it came to nursing in public. That's something all women should be able to do. Nursing moms should be able to feed their babies without being scowled at or tossed out of public places and formula feeding moms should be able to pull out a bottle and not have to explain why she is doing so. Yes, my thyroid disease meant I could no longer produce enough breastmilk to feed my babies, but I shouldn't have to explain that to anyone.
First and foremost, we're all women, we're all mothers who are in it for the good of our children and that's something even the most strident of soldiers in the Mommy Wars should remember. A little respect--from both sides--goes a long way.